That is regardless of his personal diary notes and proof from different police that he took an altered assertion from Glenn Pullin, one of many officers first on scene to the 1998 murders of Sergeant Gary Silk and Senior Constable Rodney Miller.
A annoyed Commissioner Robert Redlich advised Mr Buchhorn he was the one witness who refused to make concessions once they had been offered with proof.
“I’m not clinging on to a principle. I’m providing you with one of the best recollection I’ve,” Mr Buchhorn stated.
“You don’t have any recollection,” Mr Redlich replied, shaking his head.
“You’ve made that very clear Mr Buchhorn.”
Mr Bucchorn’s former boss, Charlie Bezzina, admitted he had signed the second assertion, which had been back-dated regardless of the modifications made to it.
Extra particulars about Senior Constable Rodney Miller’s dying declaration that there have been two offenders, not one, had been added to the second assertion for the prosecution of Bandali Debs and Jason Roberts.
The primary assertion disappeared and it wasn’t disclosed to the defence for the convicted males till a former officer blew the whistle in 2015.
In his proof on Friday, Mr Buchhorn stated Mr Bezzina’s recollection was incorrect and questioned whether or not two statements had been even made.
He stated he may solely think about talking to Mr Pullin about crime scene proof, not asking him to make one other assertion.
Jack Rush QC, the counsel aiding, requested him if he doubted Mr Bezzina’s oath to the fee earlier than accusing Mr Bucchorn of “making it up as you go”.
“Is query?” Mr Buchhorn stated.
“Sure,” Mr Rush stated.
“No [I’m not],” Mr Buchhorn replied.
Mr Buchhorn later conceded his observe on the time was to interchange authentic statements with new ones.
The general public inquiry is investigating whether or not statements used within the prosecution of Debs and Roberts, convicted in 2002, had been taken improperly.
It isn’t query the convictions of the lads, however Roberts, outdoors of the IBAC inquiry, is pushing for a re-trial.
Tammy Mills is a Crime Reporter for The Age.