The much less mentioned, the higher. That’s the mantra of any nominee earlier than the Senate, particularly when the White Home and Senate are in the identical occasion’s arms. The intention, in any case, is to win affirmation, and in these partisan occasions, an ill-chosen phrase might be damaging to a nominee’s prospects.
Like excessive courtroom nominees earlier than him, Decide Brett Kavanaugh caught to the script and mentioned solely as a lot as he thought he needed to over two days of testimony on the Senate Judiciary Committee.
WATCH: Kavanaugh jokes he’ll play on SCOTUS basketball courtroom
Nonetheless, Kavanaugh revealed a number of issues about himself, professionally and personally.
Right here are some things we discovered about President Donald Trump’s alternative for the excessive courtroom
THE REAL WORLD
Kavanaugh mentioned repeatedly that he’s conscious of the results of his selections, together with in his dissenting opinion that will have struck down Washington, D.C.’s ban on semi-automatic assault weapons.
And I need to reassure everybody that I base my selections on the regulation, however I accomplish that with an consciousness of the information and an consciousness of the actual world penalties,” Kavanaugh mentioned in a single formulation.
He famous that he grew up within the Washington space when there was lots of gang and gun violence. Some Democratic senators weren’t reassured, pointing to mass faculty shootings dedicated with semi-automatic rifles.
WATCH: Kavanaugh says president is just not proof against lawsuits
Sen. Richard Blumenthal mentioned Kavanaugh’s view on what gun management is permissible “is out of contact with actuality.”
BUT THAT’S TOO REAL
Sen. Jeff Flake, a frequent Trump critic, posed a real-world query when he requested Kavanaugh to weigh in about Trump’s current tweet that criticized Lawyer Normal Jeff Classes and the Justice Division for indicting two Republican congressman forward of the midterm elections and “placing two straightforward wins doubtful.”
Kavanaugh wouldn’t not chew on that or any query coping with Trump’s assaults on prosecutors or federal judges. “I don’t suppose we wish judges commenting on the most recent political controversy,” Kavanaugh mentioned.
Opponents of Kavanaugh’s nomination pounced on his use of sure phrases within the context of abortion and affirmative motion to claim that he was sending a sign to conservatives that he’s on their facet, regardless of his measured rhetoric.
Explaining his opinion in a case involving religiously affiliated teams that object to paying for contraception beneath the Reasonably priced Care Act, Kavanaugh referred to “abortion-inducing medicine,” a time period typically utilized by abortion opponents to explain some contraceptives.
WATCH: Kavanaugh says president might be sued for conduct earlier than presidency
Kavanaugh supporters say he was simply repeating language utilized by the teams that filed the lawsuit, although his 2015 opinion didn’t use these phrases.
SHOWING KAGAN SOME LOVE
William Rehnquist, Antonin Scalia and Anthony Kennedy could also be Kavanaugh’s judicial heroes, however the nominee invoked Justice Elena Kagan, a nominee of President Barack Obama, greater than any of them on the listening to.
Kagan’s title escaped Kavanaugh’s lips greater than 40 occasions over two days, most frequently to supply cowl for his refusal to weigh in on points that might come earlier than the courtroom. “
WATCH: Kavanaugh clarifies if he spoke about Mueller at Trump’s lawyer’s regulation agency
As Justice Kagan put it, you’ll be able to’t as a nominee on this seat give a thumbs up or thumbs down. That was — that’s her phrase,” he mentioned in declining to say whether or not Kennedy’s 2015 opinion extending same-sex marriage nationwide was appropriate.
He answered equally when requested about abortion and “simply the entire physique of recent Supreme Court docket case regulation.” Kagan, by the way, was the dean at Harvard Legislation College who employed Kavanaugh to show there.
SPEAKING OF DEMOCRATIC NOMINEES
Kavanaugh had type phrases for his appellate courtroom colleague and chief choose, Merrick Garland, whose nomination by Obama Senate was basically ignored by Republicans in 2016.
The gamble by Senate Majority Chief Mitch McConnell paid off when Trump received election and put Justice Neil Gorsuch within the seat that Justice Antonin Scalia held till his loss of life.
In opposition to that backdrop, it was considerably stunning when some Republicans on the Senate Judiciary Committee talked about how typically Kavanaugh and Garland have voted collectively on the federal appeals courtroom in Washington.
WATCH: Kavanaugh says president should adjust to regulation over torture
“What I discovered that was putting is that within the 12 years you’ve been on the D.C. Circuit, of all of the issues that you just and Chief Decide Garland have voted on collectively, that you just voted collectively 93 p.c of the time,” Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas.
Lower than two weeks earlier than the 2016 election, Cruz instructed the Senate’s refusal to behave on Garland’s nomination may proceed even when Hillary Clinton in the end received election.
Kavanaugh known as Garland “an incredible choose – an incredible chief choose, and he’s very cautious, and really hardworking, and we work nicely collectively.”
A SPORTING GUY
Soccer, baseball, basketball, hockey and lacrosse all acquired mentions from the sports-crazed Kavanaugh, who even recognized the seats he and his father had at skilled soccer video games in Washington.
On his ultimate day of testimony Thursday, Kavanaugh’s two daughters had been amongst roughly 20 women in Catholic faculty uniforms — gamers on basketball groups he has coached — who marched into the listening to room and took up seats behind Kavanaugh to make for an irresistible, if contrived, photograph op.
WATCH: Kavanaugh requested about e-mail questioning if Roe v. Wade was settled regulation
However the sports activities references didn’t cease there. He known as the Supreme Court docket a “staff of 9 dedicated to deciding instances in response to the Structure and legal guidelines of america.” That picture stood in distinction to Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes’ extra stinging description of the courtroom as “9 scorpions in a bottle.”
THE MALE BODY
One of many few occasions Kavanaugh appeared thrown, even momentarily, was when Harris, the California Democrat, discovered a brand new strategy to ask Kavanaugh about abortion.
“Are you able to consider any legal guidelines that give authorities the ability to make selections concerning the male physique?” she requested.
Kavanaugh mentioned: “I’m comfortable to reply a extra particular query. However…”
After a bit extra backwards and forwards, she repeated the query. Kavanaugh answered, “I’m not — I’m not — I’m not considering of any proper now, senator.”