An settlement between South and North Korea to march underneath a unity flag and area a joint ice hockey group at subsequent month’s Olympics was met sharp criticism by many within the South on Thursday, highlighting altering attitudes towards the nation’s northern neighbor.
The controversy reveals a South Korean public far much less wedded to the concept of inter-Korean unity than earlier generations, analysts say, a altering dynamic that will form South Korean President Moon Jae-in’s efforts at reconciliation with the remoted North.
North Korea’s participation within the Olympics has been seen as a win for Moon, who hopes to make use of the occasion to make a diplomatic breakthrough within the standoff over North Korea’s nuclear and missile program. It additionally eases public considerations the North would possibly upstage the Video games with yet one more weapons take a look at.
However Moon’s particular strikes to combine the 2 Koreas on the Pyeongchang Winter Olympics have sparked a pointy backlash that goes past his conventional conservative detractors to incorporate his principal help base of youthful South Koreans upset an unchastened North Korea is stealing the highlight.
WATCH: First indicators of thaw between North and South Korea
“North Korea was all about firing missiles final 12 months, however instantly they need to come to the South for the Olympics? Who will get to determine that?,” Kim Joo-hee, a 24-year-old translator advised Reuters throughout a espresso break on a cold Seoul afternoon.
“Does North Korea have a lot privilege to do no matter they need?”
Moon’s workplace declined to remark past saying the 2 international locations can be coordinating logistics for the Olympics, which start Feb. 9.
Opinion polls launched for the reason that plans turned public have proven restricted help for a few of Seoul’s proposals.
Solely 4 out of 10 respondents mentioned they favor the plan to march collectively underneath a flag symbolizing a unified Korea, in keeping with a survey launched on Thursday by the South Korean pollster Realmeter.
Tens of 1000’s of individuals took to social media to vent their disgust after plans for the joint actions had been introduced on Wednesday, with one commenter saying the Korean peninsula flag is “not my goddamned flag”.
Others complained, “the Pyeongchang Olympics have already grow to be the Pyongyang Olympics”.
Two totally different international locations
The South Korean ladies’s ice hockey group is the one group ear-marked for integration with the North Koreans, a transfer that drew criticism from the coach and group members anxious their efficiency can be disrupted by accommodating much less achieved North Korean gamers at brief discover.
In a go to with the group on Wednesday, Moon tried to clean issues over by telling the gamers that exhibiting unity and hope could also be extra essential than successful, and that integrating with North Koreans will deliver consideration to “a less-preferred sport”.
Nam Sung-wook, a professor of North Korean research at Korea College, mentioned the president could have come throughout as being unfair to the South Korean athletes pressured to vary their plans.
“Those that voted for Moon Jae-in final 12 months yearned for a distinct world the place equity and arduous work are valued and rewarded,” he mentioned. “However this time the Moon administration failed to understand the state of affairs and upset many individuals, together with its supporters.”
WATCH: South Korean overseas minister praises discuss with North however warns of continued nuclear build-up
Youthful South Koreans who didn’t expertise the 1950-1953 Korean Warfare or its Chilly Warfare aftermath might also have fewer cross-border ties and fewer want to reunite the peninsula than earlier generations.
“Undoubtedly we’re two totally different and separate international locations,” mentioned 26-year-old Lee Seung-kun, who works in enterprise growth. “Nobody questions that, so competing on the Olympics as ‘one nation’ does logically not make any sense.”
Andray Abrahamian, a analysis fellow at Pacific Discussion board CSIS, mentioned it was vital that plans for joint Olympic actions have upset youthful South Koreans, not solely older anti-North Korea nationalists.
“I believe that displays a rising South Korean nationalism and identification, somewhat than a extra easy anti-Communism within the older era,” Abrahamian mentioned. “Younger individuals are not anti-Communist a lot as Communism is simply form of irrelevant to them.”
The political state of affairs has additionally modified since jubilant crowds greeted a joint Korean group on the 2000 Summer time Olympics in Sydney, when many in South Korea and past sensed there may be an actual breakthrough on the horizon.
“Marching underneath the one peninsula flag doesn’t deliver peace to the Korean peninsula,” mentioned one South Korean Twitter consumer. “We did that 18 years in the past on the Sydney Summer time Olympics, however North Korea has fired missiles, performed nuclear checks and killed our personal residents. It’s simply one other political present.”
Whereas some within the Moon administration could really feel “romantic” about reconciliation with North Korea, many in South Korea now see this as a “delusion”, mentioned creator Michael Breen, who has studied South Korea for many years.
WATCH: North Korea opens hotline to South over Pyeongchang video games
“South Koreans really feel sorry for the athletes who’ve skilled so arduous for the Olympics and at the moment are being kicked out of the group to make manner for North Koreans,” he mentioned.
“They suppose there should be a greater manner, particularly as a number of months from now everyone knows we might be again to the place we had been with North Korea.”