The Consultant: Ex-intelligence official reveals covert operation to free Boyle family from militants



Within the board room of a suburban workplace constructing north of Toronto, the plan to free Joshua Boyle and his household from Haqqani Community militants was plotted on whiteboards on the partitions.

“Operation Hurriyah,” it learn throughout the highest in blue marker, utilizing the Arabic time period for freedom. “Mission – Through affect, negotiation, stress or ransom allow their secure return.”

That homecoming lastly occurred on October 13, when Boyle, 34, and his American spouse Caitlin Coleman, 32, landed at Toronto airport with their three youngsters following 5 years in captivity.

Joshua Boyle says Freedom a ‘bizarre combination of elation and depression’

They have been rescued by Pakistani troops appearing on U.S. intelligence, however World Information has discovered a Toronto-area firm headed by a former senior Canadian intelligence official additionally performed a job.

“We tried the very best we may to create a scenario the place their secure launch can be realized,” Andy Ellis, who heads The ICEN Group, stated in an unique interview.

“Our function was small however vital.”

WATCH: Learn how to keep away from getting kidnapped.

Sitting in his struggle room surrounded by whiteboards outlining the operation, Ellis revealed the rescue adopted months of behind-the-scenes work by his firm, Pakistan and notably U.S. intelligence and the White Home.

“Generally kidnap victims come house and folks say, ‘I suppose they simply allow them to go, I suppose they escaped,’” Ellis stated. “In my 32 years, I suppose, on this subject, I’ve by no means seen that occur. It’s way more advanced than that.”

ICEN was contracted by Boyle’s dad and mom to assist finish the marathon kidnapping, Ellis stated. Boyle’s father Patrick declined to remark however confirmed the household had retained The ICEN Group earlier this 12 months and that the agency had contributed to efforts to resolve the kidnapping.

Whereas the Boyle case ended fortunately, Ellis stated it nonetheless underscored the necessity to re-examine the best way the federal government handled such circumstances — every thing from Ottawa’s unclear coverage on ransoms to what he considers its aversion to dangers.

“It wants a radical assessment,” he stated.

The ICEN Group CEO Andy Ellis in the company’s board room in Vaughn, Ont.

The ICEN Group CEO Andy Ellis within the firm’s board room in Vaughn, Ont.

Stewart Bell

The saga of Coleman and Boyle, the Ottawa trial of one in every of Amanda Lindhout’s alleged Somali kidnappers, and the homicide final 12 months of two Canadians kidnapped by Abu Sayyaf within the Philippines are reminders of each traveler’s worst nightmare.

Throughout his three many years on the Canadian Safety Intelligence Service, Ellis labored on a number of worldwide kidnap circumstances and got here away feeling the federal government’s strategy was missing.

After retiring because the CSIS Assistant Director of Operations in January 2016, he started working privately with households whose family members had been kidnapped abroad. “And I grew to become keen about it,” he stated.

He launched ICEN this 12 months with retired Peel Regional Police superintendent Paul Thorne to assist Canadian firms enhance their journey security and keep away from conditions like kidnappings — and reply to crises ought to they occur.

“The ICEN Group was arrange as a result of we checked out issues like kidnapping and folks getting themselves into hazard overseas,” he stated. “If individuals had been knowledgeable and conscious of the dangers they have been going through, they might have taken measures and guarded themselves.”

“So we set this as much as fill that hole.”

Joshua Boyle’s parents ready to forgive ‘foolishness,’ help family readjust to life in Canada

In keeping with its web site, the Vaughn, Ont. firm provides “unparalleled disaster administration and response functionality” by a workforce of intelligence, regulation enforcement and army professionals. “When the unpredictable happens, we are going to carry you house safely.”

When Ellis was launched to Linda and Patrick Boyle, it had been greater than 4 years since their son and his spouse had been kidnapped by members of the Taliban-affiliated Haqqani Community whereas on a foolhardy 2012 journey to Afghanistan.

Canadian and U.S. police and diplomats had been attempting to win the help of the proper individuals in the proper nations who may enchantment to the Taliban and Haqqani Community however the efforts had stalled and the clock was working down.

An August 2016 video had stated the household can be killed if Afghanistan executed captured Taliban members. One other video in December threatened “harmful penalties” until the calls for have been met.

WATCH: What must you do if somebody tries to kidnap you?

As a former CSIS official, Ellis would have already been acquainted with the case. He stated he was moved by the dad and mom. They have been heartbroken and nervous about how the ordeal may finish.

“We felt that there was one thing that we may do for the Boyle household,” he stated.

Residents of Smiths Falls, Ont., the Boyles have been glad to have somebody like Ellis on their facet. He knew how issues labored, had intelligence contacts world wide and will symbolize their pursuits.

At first, Ellis sat in on briefings with the officers assigned to the case, serving to the dad and mom higher perceive what was happening, advocating for them and asking further questions on their behalf.

A kind of questions was about ransoms.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau delivers a statement about the death of John Ridsdel, kidnapped and murdered by Abu Sayyaf in the Philippines, in Kananaskis, Alta., April 25, 2016. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau delivers an announcement concerning the demise of John Ridsdel, kidnapped and murdered by Abu Sayyaf within the Philippines, in Kananaskis, Alta., April 25, 2016. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jeff McIntosh

Following a coverage assessment, the White Home introduced in 2015 that whereas it will not make concessions to kidnappers, households wouldn’t be prosecuted for negotiating ransom funds.

In Canada, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau had made a degree of proclaiming that Canada wouldn’t pay ransoms. However whether or not households may negotiate with kidnappers remained unsure.

And for the reason that Haqqani Community was a listed terrorist group in Canada, a ransom fee could be thought-about a terrorism offence. Ellis wished to know, what have been the principles?

The solutions have been neither clear nor reassuring, he stated.

“What’s advancing the pursuits of a terrorist group?” Ellis stated. “They’ll say, ‘We’ll by no means cost a member of the family.’ Will you cost me? I don’t know. That’s a extremely fascinating query.”

With no obvious motion on the case, the ICEN contractors grew to become “extra operational,” Ellis stated. They started pushing extra aggressively on what Ellis termed “affect operations.”

The plan was to establish the Haqqani Community’s “stressors” and exploit them in ways in which would squeeze the abductors to launch the Boyle household — or at the least to not hurt them.

The gamers listed on the whiteboards on the ICEN workplace included Basic Qamar Javed Bajwa, Pakistan’s Chief of Military Workers, who may have the ability to facilitate entry to Sami ul Haq, the Pakistani cleric often known as the Father of the Taliban.

One other was Lieutenant-Basic Naveed Mukhtar, head of Pakistan’s Inter-Providers Intelligence company, which the U.S. has accused of being carefully linked to the Haqqani Community.

ICEN additionally recruited sources who have been assigned code names for his or her safety. Certainly one of them was often known as Sabre. The contractors communicated with them securely utilizing what Ellis referred to as a “digital ahead working base” in Pakistan.

“I can’t give loads of particulars on it however I can say, sure, human sources within the space have been critically vital to our marketing campaign,” Ellis stated.

Their activity was to move on details about what was occurring on the bottom however extra importantly to affect the establishments the Haqqani Community relied upon for his or her moral and spiritual steering.

“We reached out to totally different highly-placed individuals to affect these establishments in order that these establishments would affect the abductors on areas like, for instance, you ought to not kidnap and injure and harm girls and kids,” Ellis stated.

“That had an influence.”

Sami ul Haq at Madrasa Darul Uloom Haqqania, at Akora Khattak, Pakistan, on 26 July 2017. Former students include Taliban leader Mullah Omar and Haqqani Network boss Jalaluddin Haqqani. EPA/SOHAIL SHAHZAD

Sami ul Haq at Madrasa Darul Uloom Haqqania, at Akora Khattak, Pakistan, on 26 July 2017. Former college students embrace Taliban chief Mullah Omar and Haqqani Community boss Jalaluddin Haqqani. EPA/SOHAIL SHAHZAD

Ul Haq, who heads a seminary the Western press has dubbed the College of Jihad, was an vital a part of the technique.

“We have been attempting to affect him,” Ellis stated.

The hope was that ul Haq would make it recognized to the abductors that harming girls and kids was opposite to Islamic regulation.

Joshua Boyle says Taliban-linked captors raped his wife, murdered infant daughter

Ultimately, ul Haq agreed to satisfy with Patrick and Linda Boyle, and indicated he would take into account intervening within the kidnapping. Ellis made preparations to accompany them to ul Haq’s headquarters close to Peshawar.

The Canadian authorities, nevertheless, declined to assist with the journey, contemplating it too harmful and advising towards it, Ellis stated. Ottawa wouldn’t even assist them get Pakistani visas, he stated.

A personal safety workforce was contracted to assist with the go to. Former particular forces members have been to journey from Canada. Armored automobiles have been employed and placed on standby.

“Myself and Mr. and Mrs. Boyle had a plan to journey to Pakistan and meet with a infamous influencer, chief within the Taliban and Haqqani Community, meet with him personally at a spot referred to as the Darul Haqqania in Pakistan, a really harmful space of Pakistan,” Ellis stated. “Massively dangerous however we’d reached the purpose the place after 5 years one thing must be carried out to push issues.”

However then a window appeared to open.

The abductors have been beneath stress to finish it and the U.S. had discovered their compound. Maybe fearing the optics of the Boyles’ pending go to, to not point out the likelihood the U.S. army may mount a rescue itself, Pakistan appeared keen to take motion.

“We’re placing stress on them from an ethical, moral, non secular interpretation of what they’re doing, after which they added to that that the American intelligence neighborhood have been in a position to affect sufficient issues to make the abductors transfer the hostages,” Ellis stated.

“I can’t get into why or how or anything however you already know that the abductors are shifting the hostages and now the Individuals – and that is the place, frankly, the White Home and the remainder of the administration deserves credit score – they took the danger to share that with the Pakistanis, a danger that they didn’t take with bin Laden, for instance, extremely worthwhile info shared with the Pakistani authorities, who to their credit score acted on it and saved lives.”

“It labored and it labored in response to plan, that’s most likely one of the best ways I can put it.”

WATCH: What to do should you get kidnapped.

Apparently anticipating a ransom, the abductors put the household within the trunk of a automobile. Tipped off by the Individuals, Pakistani forces have been ready within the northwest Kurram Company to intercept them and free the household.

“Hijackers and kidnappers ought to be conscious that in at the moment’s world intelligence organizations are very, excellent. And should you kidnap individuals you’re going to pay the value for it on the finish,” Ellis stated. “And I feel the Pakistani army’s intervention to rescue the household confirmed that. The abductors misplaced their lives within the firefight considering they have been about to win the lottery on the discharge of the hostages.”

The assembly with ul Haq wasn’t wanted ultimately and Ellis stated he couldn’t say for sure the conservative cleric had instructed the abductors to free the household. “I’m unsure,” he stated. “I might hope so.”

Neither World Affairs Canada nor the RCMP would remark particularly on the case.

“Each time a tragedy like this happens, we do our utmost to offer help to households and likewise to have interaction with worldwide companions,” stated Brendan Sutton, a World Affairs spokesman. “In all hostage circumstances, Canada works carefully with international authorities and its allies, at each stage, to free Canadians and produce them house.”

WATCH: What to do should you get kidnapped – and armed rescuers come for you

The day after the rescue, Overseas Affairs Minister Chrystia Freeland stated Canada had been “actively engaged” with america, Afghanistan and Pakistan governments.

Nevertheless it’s unsure what function Canada performed in ending the kidnapping. Ellis stated Ottawa had engaged in diplomacy however that finally it was U.S. intelligence and Pakistani army motion, supported by the stress marketing campaign, that obtained outcomes.

Ellis stated a coverage rethink was wanted in Ottawa, which he believes is simply too risk-averse when Canadians are kidnapped overseas, unwilling to take possibilities that might have a political backlash if issues go badly.

He isn’t satisfied Canada even has a coherent kidnap coverage, and felt that many issues weren’t carried out nicely within the Boyle case.

“I feel the entire authorities system, of the best way we deal with these sort of conditions in Canada, wants a deep look.”

[email protected]

© 2017 World Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.


Source link