Will Chicago Prosecutors Let Guevara’s Defendants Go?

29

Buy Organic Traffic | Cheap Organic Traffic | Increase Organic Traffic | Organic Traffic



Jon Lowenstein for BuzzFeed Information; Courtesy Exoneration Venture; Alyssa Schukar for BuzzFeed Information

High row, from left: Juan Johnson, Daniel Rodriguez, Antonio McDowell, Jose Montanez; Second row: Manuel Rivera, Angel Rodriguez, Roberto Almodovar; Third row: Armando Serrano, Jacques Rivera, Thomas Sierra, Jose Melendez.

Prepare dinner County Circuit Courtroom Choose James Obbish didn’t mince phrases. Throughout a listening to final month in a double homicide case, the decide stated retired Chicago police detective Reynaldo Guevara had advised “bald-faced lies” about his investigation. Guevara, the decide added, had “now eradicated the potential of being a reputable witness in any continuing.”

Prosecutors responded swiftly: They dismissed homicide fees towards the 2 males, Gabriel Solache and Arturo Reyes, releasing them from jail after 19 years.

However the decide’s phrases underscored a serious downside for the Prepare dinner County State’s Lawyer’s Workplace. BuzzFeed Information has discovered that a minimum of 54 different individuals have additionally accused the disgraced detective, in court docket papers or interviews, of framing them.

If the decide’s phrases made it not possible to maintain Solache and Reyes behind bars, what ought to the prosecutors do about all of the others?

Kim Foxx, the newly put in state’s legal professional, has assigned her prime deputy to guide what she stated could be a radical evaluation of Guevara circumstances. Earlier this month, her workplace dismissed fees towards a Guevara defendant, Thomas Sierra, 11 days after a BuzzFeed Information investigation detailed vital holes in Guevara’s case towards him.

In complete, 13 of the 56 Guevara defendants have been exonerated, together with Roberto Almodovar, the imprisoned man profiled by BuzzFeed Information final April. One other 4 defendants had been acquitted at trial.

However that leaves a minimum of 39 individuals — 38 males and one lady — who declare that they had been unjustly convicted of homicide, largely due to Detective Guevara.

Up to now, prosecutors have let these convictions stand — and in some circumstances have actively opposed the defendants’ makes an attempt to clear their names or win their freedom.

Acquired a tip? You’ll be able to e-mail [email protected] To discover ways to attain us securely, go to suggestions.buzzfeed.com.

The State’s Lawyer’s Workplace stated this week it’s performing a case-by-case evaluation of each Guevara conviction, however declined to remark additional.

Guevara has persistently declined to touch upon his police work, and when requested to take action in court docket or in depositions has repeatedly invoked his Fifth Modification proper towards self-incrimination.

This week, two Guevara defendants, Ricardo Rodriguez and Johnny Flores — each of whom say they’re harmless — will probably be in court docket for post-conviction hearings. These males, too, say Guevara framed them. Rodriguez was sentenced to 60 years in a 1995 killing of a homeless man. Flores was convicted in 1990 of homicide. Rodriguez’s case is about for a listening to at this time; Flores is due again in court docket on Wednesday.

No less than 17 extra Guevara defendants have filed post-conviction petitions, and their circumstances are slowly making their manner by the system. However extra defendants haven’t even filed — or haven’t filed correctly as a result of they’re representing themselves.

BuzzFeed Information compiled its checklist of Guevara defendants by digging by many years’ price of court docket recordsdata and police information; knocking on doorways in and round Chicago’s Humboldt Park neighborhood, the place Guevara as soon as patrolled; and interviewing dozens of attorneys and activists who tried for many years to ring the alarm about Guevara’s techniques. It’s not a complete checklist. BuzzFeed Information continues to be uncovering extra circumstances from Guevara’s 30-year profession, throughout which he was referred to as one of many police division’s prolific “closers,” somebody who was capable of clear up circumstances nobody else might.

Lots of the convicted defendants on this checklist — a few of whom could in truth have dedicated the crimes for which they had been charged — have made related claims about Guevara’s strategies. Thirty-seven males have alleged that the detective tampered with witnesses of their case, telling them whom to pick of a lineup or pressuring them into figuring out particular suspects, a serious violation of police process.

Daniel Rodriguez, for instance, was charged with being behind the wheel in a 1991 drive-by taking pictures. The state’s key witness testified at trial that Guevara pressured him to establish Rodriguez, however he was sentenced to 25 years anyway. He’s nonetheless looking for to clear his title. “I’m OK,” he stated earlier this month by tears. “I simply need them to apologize to my daughters for taking me away from them.” When he returned house from jail, his child ladies had grown into younger girls.

Fifteen males declare that the detective beat them till they confessed. One other 14 say Guevara tricked or pressured them into signing false confessions, typically by promising they may go house in the event that they acquiesced. Elvis Sanchez — who was 14 years outdated and unable to learn or write when Guevara advised him that if he signed this assertion, he might go house — accomplished his sentence 16 years in the past however requested a reporter, “Are you able to assist me?” with the homicide conviction that also mars his life, complicating his job and housing functions.

Jennifer Bonjean, a lawyer who has represented three Guevara defendants exonerated within the final 18 months, argued that any case that Guevara touched ought to get a brand new listening to.

And as for circumstances through which Guevara’s testimony is the majority of the case, Bonjean stated these “needs to be thrown out instantly.”


Standing: Incarcerated; 90-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Witnesses to a gang shoot-out stated the shooter was dark-skinned; Abrego is a white Latino. One of many survivors stated in court docket papers that Guevara advised him to pick Abrego from the lineup. A girlfriend of a person who typically matched the witnesses’ description testified that two days after the homicide, her boyfriend confessed to killing a person. Abrego claims in court docket papers that one among Guevara’s colleagues punched him repeatedly, to the purpose that he vomited blood and falsely confessed to the homicide.

Standing: Paroled; 50-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Two brothers declare — in court docket papers and in interviews with BuzzFeed Information — that Guevara pressured them into falsely figuring out Colon as a killer.

Standing: Incarcerated; 90-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

In response to Cruz’s legal professional, two witnesses to a homicide described the shooter as black. Cruz is a Hispanic with a medium complexion. A 3rd witness was proven a photograph of Cruz on the evening in query and didn’t choose him. That witness solely recognized Cruz after the witness’s title and tackle had been printed within the newspaper. This identification is the one proof linking Cruz to the crime.

Standing: Incarcerated; 50-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering, lineup manipulation

Davila claims, in a proper grievance towards Guevara, that at his lineup the detective singled him out, telling him and nobody else to carry up his shirt and reveal a tattoo. Two witnesses say that on the time of the homicide for which Davila was convicted, he was on a pay cellphone, speaking to his girlfriend.

Standing: Incarcerated; 40-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Lineup manipulation

4 months after the taking pictures of two males, Guevara claimed that gang members — he by no means named them — advised him Flores was the shooter. In response to court docket papers, Guevara confirmed the one identified witness, who was alleged to have been drunk on the time of the taking pictures, a photograph lineup and a stay lineup. Flores was the one individual to seem in each — a method that’s now linked with defective identifications. His post-conviction petition is scheduled for a listening to Wednesday.

Standing: Incarcerated; 85-year-sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Frias stated in an affidavit that Guevara, together with two different officers, beat him. When his nephew arrived on the station with Frias’s spouse and baby, Guevara allegedly beat Frias’s nephew, too. Frias stated within the sworn assertion that Guevara then warned him that his spouse could be subsequent if Frias didn’t confess. Guevara advised Frias that he would ship each him and his spouse to jail and his baby could be taken away, based on the affidavit. Frias stated he agreed to inform the detective something he wished, and Guevara fed him details about the crime. Frias is at the moment awaiting DNA testing from the crime scene.

Standing: Paroled; 35-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witnesses tampering, suppressing proof, beating, coerced assertion

Three witnesses offered sworn statements that Guevara pressured them into figuring out Gomez as the person who fired a bullet, killing a bystander. A kind of witnesses stated she advised Guevara completely different individual had fired the shot; she stated Guevara advised her that if she refused to recite what he advised her, the investigation would not be needing her testimony. A brand new evaluation of the bullet trajectories proved that Gomez couldn’t have fired the lethal shot, based on his legal professionals, and the kind of bullet didn’t match Gomez’s gun. Furthermore, a court docket dismissed the conviction of Gomez’s codefendant as a result of it discovered that there was inadequate proof that Gomez was the shooter. Gomez alleges in court docket papers that the detective bodily abused him over 12 hours, coercing him to supply an announcement. Gomez’s conviction stands to at the present time. He’s due again in court docket in February.

Standing: Incarcerated; life sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating

Gonzalez claimed in an interview that Guevara beat him into signing a false confession to a double homicide. In the identical interview, he stated the detective refused his repeated requests for a lawyer throughout his interrogation. Final November, prosecutors dropped fees towards Gonzalez’s codefendant, Jose Maysonet, as a result of Guevara and 4 different officers refused to testify within the case.

Standing: Incarcerated; 42-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Lineup manipulation

Guevara confirmed witnesses a photograph lineup through which Gonzalez’s photograph stood out — that includes numbers and a white background versus darkish backgrounds and no numbers for the others, based on court docket papers. Forensic science finds that variations like these can heighten the possibilities of a wrongful identification. Guevara additionally didn’t separate two witnesses who seen Gonzalez in a lineup, based on court docket papers, one other breach of correct identification protocol. The witnesses within the case — one among whom was drunk on the time of the taking pictures — claimed the shooter wore a T-shirt over his head and had a gold tooth. Gonzalez doesn’t have a gold tooth. No bodily proof ties him to the crime.

Standing: Incarcerated; 111-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

The case of a teen who was killed whereas listening to music on his entrance porch was one other that police stated they solved due to info from an nameless caller. The case hinges on eyewitness testimony from individuals who had been themselves beneath hearth on the time they noticed the crime — a situation eyewitness specialists say lessens the accuracy of the identifications. Juan Hernandez filed a proper grievance with the Chicago Police Division alleging that he had been framed. He alleges in interviews with BuzzFeed Information that he and his brother had been framed as payback for his position a drug ring led by a former Guevara colleague, Space 5 supervisor, and convicted drug kingpin, Joseph Miedzianowski, who’s serving a life sentence.

Standing: Incarcerated; 100-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Like his brother, Juan (above), Hernandez was charged with murdering a teen after police say they received an nameless tip. His brother alleges in interviews with BuzzFeed Information that they had been framed as payback for Juan’s actions in a drug ring run by one among Guevara’s former colleagues, who’s serving a life sentence.

Standing: Incarcerated; 25-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

The witness who gave the decisive testimony within the case later stated beneath oath that Guevara used an excellent warrant for her arrest to stress her into making identifications within the case. She testified that she by no means noticed the defendant’s face and that she signed an announcement implicating Martinez and his two codefendants as a result of she’d been on the station “too lengthy” and wished to return house. On the time he was arrested, Martinez gave a written confession to Guevara, however has since recanted.

Standing: Incarcerated; 103-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Days after McDowell was the sufferer of a taking pictures, he stated in interviews with BuzzFeed Information, Guevara introduced him to the police station and requested him to view footage of suspects. However when he arrived, he stated, Guevara positioned him in a lineup for a murder-carjacking case that had gone chilly. Witness statements, the one proof within the case, had been conflicting and typically physics-defying. A protection witness testified that he and McDowell had been collectively shopping for Christmas presents on the mall on the time of the crime. Whereas in jail, McDowell stated in an interview with BuzzFeed Information, he met one other inmate who stated he suspected that his buddy was the killer. That buddy was arrested on the day of the homicide not removed from the scene on a drug cost.

Pablo Molina

Standing: Incarcerated; 45-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Molina advised BuzzFeed Information the detective coached witnesses to establish him in a lineup.

Standing: Incarcerated; sentenced to loss of life; sentence commuted to life in jail by former governor George Ryan
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Coerced confession, witness tampering

Mulero stated in a authorized submitting that Guevara manipulated her into signing a false assertion implicating her in a double homicide. She claimed that if the officers had truly investigated her case, the proof would have proven key witness was incapable of seeing what she claimed to have witnessed. Her codefendant, Jacqueline Montanez, has stated she was chargeable for each murders.

Standing: On parole
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, witness tampering

Munoz stated in an affidavit that Guevara repeatedly punched him within the mouth and drove him into rival gang territory the place the detective allowed gang members to spit on Munoz — all in an effort to coerce him into confessing to a homicide he stated he didn’t commit. His mother and father testified at trial that he was at house with them on the time of the homicide. A predominant witness at trial later alleged, based on court docket papers, that he was pressured into figuring out Munoz.

Standing: On parole; nonetheless convicted
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Coerced confession

Rivera stated in an affidavit that Guevara advised him if he confessed, he might go house, and he would serve seven years in jail as a substitute of 40 to 50. He signed an announcement that he stated officers fed him. He stated Guevara warned him he couldn’t modify it.

Standing: Incarcerated; 80-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Rivera accuses Guevara of chaining him to a wall and repeatedly putting him within the neck and in any other case bodily intimidating him with the intention to coerce a confession, based on court docket papers.

Nelson Rivera

Standing: Incarcerated; serving life sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Rivera stated in a letter to BuzzFeed Information that Guevara struck him within the head and ribs. He stated he ultimately confessed after Guevara threatened to jail Rivera’s pregnant girlfriend. He stated he has a post-conviction petition pending.

Standing: Incarcerated; 60-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

One of many two witnesses who initially recognized Rodriguez within the deadly taking pictures of a homeless man has since stated beneath oath that he was “100%” not the killer and that he initially recognized Rodriguez solely due to the actual fact he “regarded slightly acquainted and the affect by the detectives.” The witness stated he felt “caught” into making the ID. Rodriguez has offered an alibi for the time of the homicide.

Adolfo Rosario

Standing: On parole
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Manipulated a lineup through which Rosario was recognized because the killer

In response to an interview with Rosario’s former lawyer, Rosario accused the detective of manipulating a lineup by putting a pink X on Rosario’s hand as a sign of whom to pick from the lineup.

Anthony Rosario

Standing: Incarcerated; 45-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering, lineup manipulation

Though a codefendant within the crime named Rosario because the shooter moments after the crime, and earlier than Guevara was concerned, police information present second witness whom Guevara interviewed described Rosario in additional particular element — together with his pockmarked pores and skin — than would have been doable to see, given how distant he was and the way darkish it was.

Manuel Suastegui

Standing: Incarcerated; 45-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

A witness gave sworn testimony that Guevara pressured him to establish a killer on this case. One other key witness was going through drug fees, which Suastegui stated in interviews with BuzzFeed Information gave him an incentive to falsely implicate Suastegui in hopes of favorable therapy by the officers.

Alan Vega

Standing: Incarcerated; 35-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Vega has alleged in an interview with BuzzFeed Information that witnesses had been pressured into figuring out him and that he had an alibi.


Standing: Served 22 years; accomplished sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

An individual with a heroin dependancy claimed over the span of six weeks to have collected confessions in two different homicide circumstances; he testified that Bouto confessed to killing a teenage boy exterior a highschool. That confession allegedly got here whereas each had been being held at a police station lockup, which might have meant Bouto shouted it throughout jail cells inside earshot of guards. The individual with the heroin dependancy later signed an affidavit alleging Guevara plied him with meals, clothes, and sexual contact visits with a girlfriend whereas he was in custody in alternate for his testimony implicating others in homicide. One other key witness — who stated he was conscious of Guevara’s popularity for framing individuals for homicide — stated the detective pressured him to establish Bouto because the killer. Bouto didn’t have a ponytail as a number of witnesses claimed the killer did, and he additionally had an alibi corroborated by two different individuals. An impartial metropolis investigation concluded that Bouto was seemingly harmless.

Standing: Trial resulted in hung jury; took a plea deal slightly than face a retrial; deported to Poland
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Dembski claimed Guevara handcuffed him to a wall and repeatedly struck him, based on his lawyer. A Polish immigrant, Dembski signed a confession in English, a language he didn’t converse. His lawyer stated in an affidavit that Dembski requested for an legal professional a number of instances however was refused.

Standing: Accomplished jail sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Duta swore beneath oath that Guevara hit him repeatedly and advised him he might go house if he signed a false confession that the detective wrote out. Duta’s father stated in court docket papers his son suffers from a “extreme studying incapacity” that leaves him “fairly impressionable.”

Mario Flores

Standing: Sentenced to loss of life; sentence was commuted to time served in 2003 when Gov. George Ryan emptied loss of life row
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating

Guevara stated in police information he obtained an nameless name linking Flores to a chilly case homicide dedicated 11 months earlier. When he arrived on the Flores house, Guevara beat two of Flores’ teenaged sisters, based on court docket testimony. The important thing witness on the trial claimed to have seen Flores accosting the sufferer exterior her house, regardless of very difficult sightlines. Flores had an alibi that he was at house, celebrating the brand new 12 months with household and mates.

Standing: Sentenced to 90 years, conviction overturned; pleaded responsible at retrial
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession, witness tampering

Flores, who was 17 and couldn’t learn or write, stated in an affidavit that Guevara handcuffed him to the wall, repeatedly slapped him within the head, and advised him that if he didn’t confess, he would “by no means see daylight once more.” The teenager stated in a sworn assertion that Guevara repeatedly ignored his requests for an legal professional — a discovering that ultimately led the Illinois appellate court docket to toss his conviction and order a brand new trial. The girlfriend of Flores’ codefendant testified that Guevara threatened to take her youngsters from her and known as her names. She stated she didn’t learn the assertion she was given implicating Flores and that she signed it “simply to get out” of the police station.

Standing: Died whereas serving a 50-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Mendacity on police experiences

One other man was initially linked to the scene of a double homicide, however Guevara, who knew the person’s household, filed a police report that stated he was not concerned, based on court docket information. One in all Guevara’s colleagues filed experiences that contradicted Guevara’s account of the crime. Gonzalez was arrested on the day of the crime however examined destructive for gunshot residue on his arms.

Nelson Gonzalez

Standing: Accomplished 45-year jail sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Mendacity

Gonzalez claimed in an interview with BuzzFeed Information that Guevara fabricated an nameless cellphone name with the intention to hyperlink Gonzalez to the crime. Witnesses within the case had been consuming. Gonzalez stated that he was in Indiana for Father’s Day when the homicide came about. None of his alibi witnesses had been known as to testify at trial.

Standing: Accomplished his 38-year sentence; incarcerated on one other, unrelated crime
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Hunt claims in court docket papers he confessed to a homicide that he didn’t commit as a result of Guevara and different officers beat him, denied him meals and water, and ignored his requests for a lawyer. Hunt later gained a settlement towards town of Chicago.

Geraldo Iglesias

Standing: Accomplished sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

The identical individual with the heroin dependancy who claimed to have collected confessions in two different homicide circumstances over a span of six weeks claimed that Iglesias confessed to him, an ideal stranger, whereas each had been being transported to court docket. The individual with the heroin dependancy later signed an affidavit alleging Guevara helped present him with meals, clothes, and sexual contact visits with a girlfriend whereas he was in custody in alternate for his testimony. Iglesias didn’t match the descriptions given by witnesses to the homicide. He claimed he had been in his house, caring for his younger baby, on the time of the killing.

Standing: Conviction tossed however accepted a plea deal slightly than danger a retrial
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Key witnesses later testified that Guevara advised them to establish brothers Juan and Henry Johnson as culprits in a deadly beating exterior a nightclub. One witness testified he understood Guevara’s directions as a risk to conform or be charged. After an appeals court docket tossed the brothers’ convictions, Henry accepted a plea deal for time served slightly than danger a retrial. His brother and codefendant, Juan, was acquitted at a retrial and later sued town of Chicago for Guevara’s misconduct. He gained a $16.four million settlement.

Standing: Died behind bars; nonetheless convicted
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Pena testified that he falsely confessed after Guevara repeatedly hit him together with his arms and a flashlight. Pena complained of the abuse to a physician on the jail shortly after his arrest. The physician documented bruises to Pena’s legs and cuts to his face. Pena additionally testified that he was illiterate and couldn’t learn the assertion he had signed. He died in jail lower than two years after his trial.

Standing: Accomplished a 50-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

An eyewitness to a homicide in a park stated in a sworn assertion that Guevara pointed to an image of Rivera and advised him to pick Rivera because the killer. The witness later stated beneath oath that Rivera wasn’t on the crime scene however that the witness feared if he didn’t cooperate with Guevara, he could be charged with homicide himself.

Standing: Accomplished his 25-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Rodriguez claimed in an affidavit and in interviews with BuzzFeed Information that Guevara threatened to arrest the mom of his baby except he confessed to a drive-by homicide. Rodriguez stated Guevara left him cuffed to a wall, depriving him of meals, water, and entry to a restroom. A key witness within the case testified that Guevara beat him into figuring out Rodriguez as the driving force and his codefendant, George Laureano, because the shooter. Laureano was acquitted at trial.

Elvis Sanchez

Standing: Accomplished 20-year sentence
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Coerced confession

Sanchez, who was 14 on the time of his arrest, stated in interviews with BuzzFeed Information the detective pressured him to signal a confession that the boy couldn’t learn as a result of he was illiterate.

Standing: Accomplished a 38-year sentence; nonetheless convicted
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering, coerced confession

A key prosecution witness stated in an affidavit that Guevara confirmed him Vera’s image earlier than a lineup — a breach of police identification procedures — and that the detective threatened him and one other witness that in the event that they didn’t choose Vera, they “had been going to have hassle.” Vera stated in a sworn assertion that Guevara coerced his confession by threatening to arrest his mother and father and by driving him into the territory of rival gang members who wished to hurt him. Vera stated Guevara used a bullhorn to alert rival gang members to Vera’s presence.


Standing: Exonerated after serving 23 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

One in all two witnesses testified that Guevara manipulated his identification by exhibiting him images of Almodovar and his codefendant, William Negron, earlier than the lineup. Almodovar had 5 alibi witnesses for the time of the homicide.

Standing: Exonerated
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

A predominant state’s witness testified at trial that Guevara threatened that if he didn’t establish Arcos for the homicide, he could be pinned with the crime. The witness claimed that Guevara fed him particulars of the crime. An Illinois appeals court docket overturned Arcos’s conviction.

Standing: Exonerated after serving 11 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Key witnesses to a deadly beating exterior a nightclub later testified that Guevara advised them to establish brothers Juan and Henry Johnson because the killers. One witness testified that he understood Guevara’s directions as a risk that the witness both comply or be charged himself. After an appeals court docket tossed the brothers’ convictions, Juan was discovered not responsible at a retrial. Juan later sued town for Guevara’s misconduct. He gained a $16.four million settlement from town of Chicago.

Standing: Exonerated after serving 27 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating

Maysonet claimed in court docket papers Guevara beat him with a flashlight till he falsely confessed to murdering two brothers. His lawyer stated in court docket that Maysonet, a former drug seller, made repeated funds to the detective for him to look the opposite manner when Maysonet was dealing medication. After Maysonet stopped making the funds, Guevara charged him with the double murder. Final November, prosecutors dropped the fees towards Maysonet after Guevara and 4 different officers refused to testify in his case.

Standing: Exonerated after 23 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Guevara allegedly coerced an individual with a heroin dependancy into claiming that Montanez, alongside together with his codefendants Armando Serrano and Jorge Pacheco, confessed to an early-morning taking pictures of a manufacturing unit employee. The individual with the heroin dependancy later alleged that the detectives plied him with meals, clothes, and sexual contact with a girlfriend whereas in custody in alternate for his testimony. He provided testimony that two different males in two different circumstances had additionally confessed to him, all inside weeks of one another. Officers additionally relied on a witness who claimed he noticed the homicide, although it will have been practically not possible given his vantage level. Montanez and his codefendant Serrano’s convictions had been tossed in 2016 after the appellate court docket discovered “profoundly alarming acts of misconduct” within the case. Montanez’s different codefendant, Pacheco, had his conviction tossed years earlier.

Standing: Exonerated; awaiting resentencing in an unrelated case
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

One in all two witnesses testified that Guevara manipulated his identification by exhibiting him images of Negron and his codefendant, Almodovar, earlier than the lineup.

Standing: Exonerated; deceased
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Guevara allegedly coerced an individual with a heroin dependancy into claiming that Pacheco, together with codefendants Jose Montanez and Armando Serrano, confessed to the early-morning taking pictures of a manufacturing unit employee. The individual later alleged in an affidavit that the detectives plied him with meals, clothes, and sexual contact with a girlfriend whereas in custody in alternate for his testimony. He provided testimony that two different males in two different circumstances had additionally confessed to him, all inside weeks of one another. Pacheco’s conviction was tossed shortly after the trial.

Standing: Exonerated after serving 19 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Over the course of three days, Reyes stated in court docket filings, Guevara repeatedly beat him till he signed a false confession within the grisly stabbing deaths of a younger couple and the kidnapping of their youngsters. No bodily proof linked him to the crime. His codefendant, Gabriel Solache, testified that he, too, was crushed. A metropolis investigation of his case discovered it seemingly that Guevara beat Reyes.

Standing: Exonerated after serving 23 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

The one surviving witness to the homicide, who was 12 years outdated on the time, testified that Guevara pressured him to establish Rivera because the killer. The sufferer within the case named one other man as his killer to different officers earlier than dying at a hospital.

Standing: Exonerated after serving three years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

The important thing witness within the case, a teen, stated to attorneys investigating Guevara that the detective advised him whom choose from the lineup, based on a court docket submitting.

Standing: Exonerated after serving 23 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

Guevara allegedly coerced an individual with a heroin dependancy into claiming that Serrano, together with codefendants Jose Montanez and Jorge Pacheco, confessed to an early-morning taking pictures of a manufacturing unit employee. The individual later alleged in an affidavit that the detectives plied him with meals, clothes, and sexual contact with a girlfriend whereas in custody in alternate for his testimony. He provided testimony that two different males in two different circumstances had additionally confessed to him, all inside weeks of one another. Officers additionally used a witness who claimed he noticed the homicide, although it will have been practically not possible for the person to have seen the crime from the vantage level he described. Serrano and his codefendant Montanez’s convictions had been overturned in 2016 after the appellate court docket discovered “profoundly alarming acts of misconduct” within the case. Serrano’s different codefendant, Pacheco, had his conviction tossed years earlier.

Standing: Exonerated; served 22 years in jail
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Lineup and witness tampering

Guevara is accused in court docket papers of violating protocols meant to protect towards wrongful identifications when he held a photograph of Thomas Sierra in his hand, aside from others in a photograph lineup. The witness viewing that photograph array testified that although he didn’t get a transparent view of the shooter, Guevara influenced him to pick Sierra. Guevara additionally reported that two witnesses positively recognized a automobile that supposedly linked Sierra to the homicide. But each of these witnesses testified that they advised Guevara that the automobile wasn’t a match with the killer’s.

Standing: Exonerated after serving 19 years
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, coerced confession

Solache testified that Guevara repeatedly beat him till he signed a false confession within the grisly stabbing deaths of a younger couple and kidnapping of their youngsters. No bodily proof linked him to the crime. His codefendant, Arturo Reyes, alleged that he, too, was crushed. A metropolis investigation of his case discovered it seemingly that Guevara beat Solache.


Standing: Acquitted
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

A key witness in Laureano’s case testified that the detective handcuffed him to a hoop in an interrogation room and threatened to “get you for something I can” if the witness didn’t cooperate. One witness recanted his identification of Laureano at trial and stated that Guevara fed him particulars of the homicide. Laureano was acquitted.

Standing: Acquitted at trial
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Beating, witness tampering

Melendez advised BuzzFeed Information that Guevara repeatedly struck him to get him to admit to homicide, which he refused to do. The witness statements towards him contained obvious contradictions when lined up with the bodily proof from the scene and statements from different witnesses.

Standing: Acquitted at trial
Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

The primary witness within the 1997 taking pictures loss of life of one among Guevara’s nephews testified that the detective detained him repeatedly till he agreed to make an identification. The witness testified at trial that Guevara advised him to establish brothers Freddy and Concepcion Santiago because the killers and advised him what to say in his assertion. The decide chastised Guevara for main an investigation involving somebody in his family. In 2001, the brothers settled a civil go well with with town of Chicago and Guevara for $45,000.

Standing: Acquitted at trial

Guevara’s alleged misconduct: Witness tampering

The primary witness within the 1997 taking pictures loss of life of one among Guevara’s nephews testified that the detective repeatedly detained him till he agreed to make an identification. The witness testified at trial that Guevara advised him to establish brothers Freddy and Concepcion Santiago because the killers and advised him what to say in his assertion. The decide chastised Guevara for main an investigation involving the detective’s household. In 2001, the brothers settled a civil go well with with town of Chicago and Guevara for $45,000.


Do you’ve gotten a tip or info we must always know? You’ll be able to e-mail [email protected] To discover ways to attain us securely, go to suggestions.buzzfeed.com.

Acquired a confidential tip? Submit it right here.

Buy Website Traffic | Cheap Website Traffic | Increase Website Traffic | Website Traffic



Source link