CNET 25: The Firsts – CNET


Revealed: The Secrets our Clients Used to Earn $3 Billion

Sarah Tew/CNET

This story belongs to CNET at 25, commemorating a quarter century of market tech and our function in informing you its story.

CNET has actually seen a great deal of innovation firsts over its 25-year history, and our customers have actually been here to evaluate every noteworthy brand-new piece of hardware from the previous quarter century. I’ve been on the item examines group for 15 of those 25 years, and I’ve seen a lot of these first-gen items up close, from the very first iPads and iPhones to the very first MacBooks and HD video gaming consoles.

While the innovation has actually altered, the concepts behind our item evaluations have not. From the start, CNET customers have actually concentrated on not just substantial hands-on screening and benchmarking, however likewise on real-world usage. Not simply specifications and functions, however how an item suits individuals’s lives and budget plans, and whether something has the possible to be genuinely helpful and ingenious, or if it’s simply the current overhyped pattern.

Looking back on our preliminary evaluations of lots of tech “firsts,” I’m happily amazed to discover that much of that believing holds up, as seen in these excerpts of essential item evaluations from the past 25 years. Note that in many cases, our initial evaluations have actually been swallowed by the web memory hole or overwritten by more recent updates, so we have actually discovered the closest variations possible or connected to existing copies on our sibling websites. 

First flip phone 

Motorola StarTac, 1996

It’s fitting that we begin with the very first smart phone that actually altered how individuals saw and utilized these typically costly, not practical, large gadgets. Motorola’s StarTac was the very first flip phone, a design that controlled for several years, and which is taking pleasure in a resurgence of sorts with folding phones. 



It was the age when everybody at a company lunch would pull their phones out and lay them on the dining establishment table, in a subtle program of who had the tiniest, most recent design. Of those, the Motorola StarTac was typically the winner.

From our evaluation of an early StarTac phone:

“Operating this phone is quite simple, even if you don’t read the manual. You navigate menus via three main buttons, with some assistance from a Smart Button and a couple of scroll buttons located on the upper left side of the phone.”

And you can forget app shops or selfie cameras. The includes we were delighted about at that time were more fundamental.

“For starters, you can assign up to four numbers to each contact in the 99-name phone book. You can also activate various call timers, including an individual timer, which displays your most recent call in hours, minutes, and seconds; and a cumulative timer, which tracks your phone’s total airtime (in hours) from the time the unit was activated. This is a convenient way to track your total monthly minutes.”

We likewise applauded the StarTac’s vibrate mode — it was among the very first phones to have one — however there is one location where an older phone like this sticks out today. ” We got about 4 hours of talk time and seven days of standby time. That’s pretty impressive.” 

First customer flat-screen TELEVISION

Philips FlatTV, 1998

Today, you can’t stroll into a huge box retailer without tripping over sophisticated flat-screen Televisions that cost simply a couple of hundred dollars. It wasn’t constantly like that — the very first years of customer flat-screens were high-end items with high-end rates.

The initially genuinely made-for-living-rooms flat-screen plasma TELEVISION was the Philips FlatTV, presented at CES 1998. When we blogged about it at that time, we pointed out that this 42-inch set consisted of some additionals, consisting of, “a built-in Dolby ProLogic sound system, with complimentary subwoofer and two rear satellite speakers.” And all this for a simple $15,000.”

Today, something like a better-than-decent 55-inch TCL TELEVISION with built-in Roku is routinely readily available for under $300, and even the most indulgent customer Televisions cost a portion of the FlatTV’s rate. If you’re actually looking for 1998-level TELEVISION rates today, want to something like Samsung’s $15K 85-inch 8K TELEVISION.

“Well, this is really aimed at enthusiasts,” a Philips VP informed CNET at the time. “Between you and me, we’re thinking maybe some of these sports figures might like one.”

Long prior to we discussed over plasma versus LCD or OLED versus MicroLED, it was everything about flat versus CRT. In 1998 we asked: “Will flat-panel displays be the wave of the future, replacing even digital, high-definition CRTs? While it waits to find out, Sharp, and most other TV-makers, are offering every kind of high-end device they can.”


Andrew Hoyle/CNET

First iPod

Apple iPod, 2001

Brett Pearce/CNET

The supreme portable music maker in the 1980s was Sony’s cassette tape Walkman. Later, it was the Discman, or an army of comparable cd gamers (which were marketed as portable, although they had a spinning disc inside and needed all sorts of wonky “anti-skip” buffers). Early digital music gamers go back to late ’90s (anybody keep in mind the Rio PMP300?), however they struggled with software application and compatibility problems, in addition to concerns over customers’ right to rip and move their own music to the gadgets. 

In 2001, Apple presented its own digital music gamer, constructed around a big capability and general ease-of-use, in addition to the then-new iTunes software application platform. Of that first-gen iPod, CNET composed:

“The product, the size of a deck of cards, was unveiled during an event at Apple’s headquarters here. The stainless-steel unit costs $399, has a 5GB hard drive, connects to a Mac using FireWire, includes a 10-hour lithium polymer battery, offers 20 minutes of anti-skip protection, and works with Mac OS 9 and Mac OS X.” 

Specs that impressed us at the time consisted of: “A screen for displaying artist name, song title and album name. The liquid-crystal display has a resolution of 160 pixels by 128 pixels and offers an LED backlight. With the FireWire port, people can download an entire CD onto the iPod in under 10 seconds and 1,000 songs in less than 10 minutes, according to the company.”

The traditional iPod is long gone, ultimately cannibalized by the iPhone, however the line resides on in the iPod Touch hardware and iTunes software application. But let’s likewise put one out for FireWire. 


James Martin/CNET

First HD Game Console 

Microsoft Xbox, 2001 

One of the couple of essential examples of modern-day innovation that precedes even CNET is the initial Sony PlayStation, very first launched in late 1994 in Japan and the list below year in the United States and in other places). Instead, we leap to the very first Microsoft Xbox, from late 2001. At the time, we currently saw how video game consoles, computer systems and set-top home entertainment boxes were coming together, assisting far-sighted tech business attack your living-room. 

When evaluating that first-ever Xbox, previous CNET editor Darren Gladstone composed:

“Microsoft’s Xbox is a Trojan horse. The company has conquered the desktop and now seems intent on sneaking a PC into your living room. Yes, this black behemoth of a system looks and acts just like a video game machine–and a state-of-the-art one at that. But with built-in support for high-speed networking, an 8GB hard drive, DVD playback capabilities, and display support for HDTVs, the Xbox does more than just play games.”

This was likewise perhaps the very first video game console to take HDTV seriously (although a minimum of one video game designer demoed high-resolution video gaming back in the ’90s). At the time, we stated: “Video enthusiasts will appreciate that the Xbox works not only with standard 4:3 TVs but with HDTVs as well. If you have an HD-ready set, you can set the Xbox to output 480p, 720p, and 1,080i signals in either normal or wide-screen (16:9) aspect ratios for your games.”

But yes, you’d need to purchase the sold-separately HD cable television pack in order to output in HD. And if you’re quickly puzzled by item identifying, remember that the Playstation has actually gone through it’s initial variation, followed by the PS2, PS3, PS4 and quickly PS5; while the Xbox was followed by the Xbox 360, Xbox One (and Xbox One X version), and the coming-soon Xbox Series X

RIM BlackBerry 5810, 2002


Research In Motion

Wait, the Xbox preceded the BlackBerry phone? Hardly feels that method, however it holds true. There was an OG BlackBerry two-way pager as far back as 1999, and the traditional RIM 957 even had some fundamental web searching functions in 1999, however neither one was a real smart device. 

That mix of phone service, QWERTY keyboard and BlackBerry Messenger initially was available in the 2002 RIM BlackBerry 5810. It was such an odd duck that we called it a “New PDA [with] a complete practical cellular phone integrated in.” That stated, it wasn’t precisely simple to utilize — you still needed to link a physical headset to utilize the phone functions. The 6210 design, from 2003, eliminated that odd requirement. 

One thing the 5810 solved was acknowledging that these gadgets are information and messaging platforms initially and phones 2nd — something the majority of us would still state about modern-day iOS and Android phones. 

Testing out the then-new 5810, we stated: “It was clear — even in our brief encounter with a demo unit — that this is primarily a data device. For instance, to place a call you have to navigate through two screens of information before you can dial.”

And forget iOS versus Android, the 5810 worked on Java 2 Micro Edition (J2ME), which enabled some then-unheard-of functions. We stated, “For example, you can select a phone number in an email, and the phone application will launch and place the call. You’ll also be able to talk on the phone while using the device’s other features.”

But we can’t mock the ancient Blackberry 5810 excessive. After all, it had a long-lost function the majority of us would enjoy to return — an earphone jack. 


Sarah Tew/CNET

First MacBook

Apple MacBook, 2006

Yes, Apple made laptop computers prior to the MacBook. The Macintosh Portable goes back to 1989 and the Powerbook to 1991. The 1999 iBook is still an authentic style classic, with its sweet colored plastic shell and the manage for simple carrying. But the very first modern-day Apple laptop computer was the MacBook, a trademark name still in usage today.

When the 10th anniversary of the MacBook Air occurred in 2018, I recalled in the CNET archives to see who composed that first-gen Air evaluation, and was really amazed to discover that I had. Going back even more to the very first Intel-powered Apple laptop computer, the initial 2006 MacBook, ends up I composed that evaluation too. (And, similar to the 2008 MacBook Air, I do not keep in mind doing it at all.) 

But I do keep in mind that the MacBook was a killer laptop computer. Even today, the matte black polycarbonate appearance (it was likewise readily available in white) holds up, and I’d wagered many individuals would purchase a throwback-looking maker. Back in 2006, I composed:

“The matte black surface is nice to run your hands over and is largely fingerprint resistant. … Opening the lid, you’ll find a minimalist setup, including a power button, a full-size keyboard, a sizable touch pad with a single mouse button, and a built-in iSight camera that sits above the display. If you miss the scroll bar present on many Windows laptops, you’ll find that the two-finger scroll option works well (run two fingers down the touch pad, and it scrolls like a mouse wheel).”

I did need to laugh when I saw the outcomes of our benchmarking. We stated: “In our battery tests, we got an impressive 3 hours, 30 minutes out of the MacBook.” Some things, nevertheless, never ever modification. Even at that time, it was everything about the upsell: “Telephone support is limited to a mere 90 days — well short of what you’d typically find on the PC side — unless you purchase the $249 AppleCare Protection Plan.” 


Sarah Tew/CNET

First iPhone

Apple iPhone, 2007

Has there been a more substantial piece of portable tech in our life times? I’ll wait. The term smart device has actually been tossed around as far back as the 1990s (hi, IBM Simon!), however this was the very first consumer-level smart device to actually offer the general public on doing without a physical keyboard and focus more on being a portable computer system than a telephone.

But did it all come together in the beginning? Back in 2007, Kent German asked: “Does it live up to the stratospheric hype?” And likewise responded to: “Not so much.”

“Don’t get us wrong, the iPhone is a lovely device with a sleek interface, top-notch music and video features, and innovative design touches. The touchscreen is easier to use than we expected, and the multimedia performs well. But a host of missing features, a dependency on a sluggish EDGE network, and variable call quality — it is a phone after all — left us wanting more. For those reasons, the iPhone is noteworthy not for what it does, but how it does it”

People will constantly grumble about information speed and call quality on their phones, however vital missing out on functions, consisting of MMS messaging and Bluetooth ultimately showed up. Also extremely relatable, our preliminary grievances about earphone assistance: “The headset jack on the top end is deeply recessed, which means you will need an adapter for any headphones with a chubby plug. Is this customer-friendly? No.” If we just understood what the future held for the earphone jack at that time…

We likewise reviewed the initial iPhone evaluation in 2017 on its 10th anniversary.

remembering the first Google Android Phone: HTC T Mobile G1

Sarah Tew/CNET

First Android phone

T-Mobile G1, 2008

The very first Android OS phone — likewise referred to as the HTC Dream/T-Mobile G1 — came simply a year after the iPhone. At that time, the fight in between physical and on-screen keyboards still raved, and this first-ever Android phone stuck to a slide-out QWERTY keyboard — a choice history has actually not recalled kindly on. 

“After a few days of use, we started to notice a creaking sound whenever we nudged the screen — not good,” stated initial customers Bonnie Cha and Nicole Lee, comparing it to the brief Sidekick, which likewise had a landscape-style slide-out keyboard. 

Even back in 2008, the iOS-versus-Android writing was on the wall. “We like that you can customize the Home screen with your favorite apps very easily,” they composed. But compared to the iPhone, “the [G1] phone’s general user interface isn’t as instinctive.” We likewise applauded its SD card slot, something the iPhone would never ever get,

There’s something the G1 was well ahead of the curve on: “On the bottom of the unit is a mini USB port where you connect the power charger. Sadly, this is also your only option for connecting a headset, as there’s no dedicated headphone jack, 3.5mm or otherwise.” Who understood how positive that would be? 

We recalled at the Dream/G1 evaluation 10 years later on, and remembered the initial gadget “a delightful mess.” 


Netflix on the iPad.

Sarah Tew/CNET

First mainstream tablet

Apple iPad, 2010

This year marks the 10th anniversary of the iPad, an extremely crucial gadget that bridged the space in between computer systems and phones, and in between developers of material and customers of material. Previous tablets, more frequently described as slates, were typically Windows-powered beasts planned for building websites or other commercial usages.

This was the tablet for the rest people.

Back in 2010, the argument racing through the CNET ranks was whether the iPad must be evaluated as a computer system or as a glorified MP3 gamer. I, representing the computer system side, lost that argument back in 2010, however history has actually shown me ideal. You can manage today’s iPads with a mouse and keyboard. Writers, professional photographers, visual artists and lots of others utilize an iPad as their primary computer system.

In 2010, I blogged about that inescapable mashup of designs: “One can envision a not-too-distant future where an iPhone-style interface becomes more prevalent on small Netbook and smartbook systems, rather than a full PC OS trickling down to ever-smaller devices.”

Reviewer Donald Bell took the OG iPad to job, stating, “The absence of an integrated video camera puts the kibosh on any hope of using the iPad for video chats, and without Flash video support, many Web pages look like Swiss cheese.” He concludes that “As a jack-of-all-trades and a master of few, the iPad can’t entirely mimic many of the specialized products it seeks to replace.”

Cameras would be available in with Pad 2 and today’s iPad Pro electronic cameras even have integrated Lidar assistance for room-scanning and enhanced truth. It does appear, nevertheless, that Apple led the curve on kicking Flash to the curb, so points there. Eventually everybody dropped the frustrating web animation and user interface tool. 

Where has the iPad wound up a years later on? I’ll provide the last word to my coworker Scott Stein, who evaluated the 2020 iPad Pro in April: “I’m at my desk. I’m typing on a keyboard, using a trackpad. Looking at a nice-sized 12.9-inch screen. And yes, this is like working on a computer. I’m hesitant to say Apple’s iPad problems have been completely solved. But damn, using a real trackpad on an iPad is a magic moment that’s been three quarters of a decade overdue.”

Now playing:
Watch this:

Celebrating 25 years of CNET


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.